The KNUH news

홈 > The KNUH > The KNUH news
[The Bell No.256_Society] How Has Disney Broken Children’s Dreams?
작성자 : 영자신문
작성일 : 2021-01-26 11:58:39
조회 : 261

How Has Disney Broken Children’s Dreams?


 

Our Current Hot Potato: The New Mulan Film

 

Disney's new “Mulan” film has been embroiled in a worldwide boycott. The boycott begins with actor Liu Yifei's support for the Hong Kong police. Since then, boycotts against Mulan have begun in Hong Kong and Taiwan. Joshua Wong, Hong Kong pro-democracy activist, strongly criticized the movie. South Korea has started to boycott too. After the movie's release, the boycott spread all over the world when it was revealed that the movie’s ending credits contained special thanks to the city of Turpan, located in Xinjian Uyghur Autonomous Region. Turpan is the city where the Chinese government is suspected of violating the human rights of minorities in that region.

 

이은주 사진.jpg 359X449

▲https://biz.chosun.com/site/data/html_dir/2020/09/16/2020091602558.html


The problems with the movie are not only of political relevance to brutal inhumanity, but they are also connected to the movie’s contents implicating Orientalism: How did they describe Chinese culture? This is the key. Orientalism means prejudice or a distorted idea and attitude toward the East which Western people have expressed against people of the East. We can see a lot of orientalism in individual creative works like movies and pictures. In this context, we can also find orientalism in the new Mulan.

 

The new movie differs from the point of view of the East in many ways. Unlike the original film, Mulan was born with a special power “Qi” which makes it possible for her to win over enemies. In this movie, the “Qi” is expressed as the power of a superhero. However, its techniques come from concepts of Taoism like the ‘five elements’ and ‘Yin and Yang.’ This is just a theory that explores the origin of natural phenomena and matter. Moreover, the phoenix, used mainly in this film, does not match Eastern ideas. There is no phoenix in Eastern culture, so the appearance of a phoenix in the movie looks like strange. Unlike the phoenix of Western culture, the East has Fenghuang and the Vermilion Bird, which come from Taoism. In particular, the Vermilion Bird is well-known as Four Symbols deity along with the blue dragon, white tiger, and black tortoise. Therefore, we might conclude that the producer of new Mulan did not understand Chinese culture.

 

The most disappointing part is that the feminist message contained in the original is missing. Mulan has been forced to play the role of a woman in a traditional patriarchal society. Nevertheless, she goes beyond the limits of gender and becomes a huge success. This is in the same context as modern feminist messages like, “Girls can do anything.” The two movies have similar backgrounds but different ways of achieving success. The 1998 original Mulan succeeds through her individual effort, but the new Mulan succeeds through her special power “Qi”. Removing all the contents of the original and emphasizing Mulan's special abilities does not match the feminist values that the original pursued.

 

Unlike the traditional Disney princesses who waited for the Prince, Mulan solved her problems and grew up by herself. However, the new Mulan stresses different values from the previous Mulan. Disney films influence the values of many children, so this movie will forever impact the values of and perspectives of its young viewers. China is also taking a critical attitude toward the new Mulan movie. If the production team had had a better understanding of Chinese culture, Mulan (2020) would have been a better movie.

 

Lee Eun Ju

<ibeunju@naver.com>